Kim Davis Owes a Gay Couple $565,000. A Judge Wants to Know About Her Inheritance

A federal judge says the former Kentucky clerk who refused marriage licenses in 2015 didn't disclose an inheritance while she still owes David Ermold and David Moore. Her deadline is Nov. 16.

Share
A neoclassical courthouse facade

Eleven years after she refused to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples in Rowan County, Kentucky, Kim Davis is back in front of a federal judge, and this time the question is about money.

In an order filed Nov. 6, U.S. Magistrate Judge Edward Adkins found that Davis had not fully disclosed her assets while a judgment of more than $565,000 owed to David Ermold and David Moore remains unpaid, according to WKYT and WEKU. She has until Sunday, Nov. 16, to correct her answers and explain why she should not be sanctioned. The story has been trending on X this week.

How we got here

In 2015, Davis, then the Rowan County clerk, refused to issue marriage licenses after the U.S. Supreme Court's Obergefell decision, citing her religious beliefs. She was jailed for contempt. Ermold and Moore, one of the couples she turned away, sued. A federal jury ruled in their favour in 2023; with damages, attorneys' fees and costs, the amount owed now stands at $565,285.91, WEKU reports. On May 6, 2026, the couple were awarded a further $201,592.60 in fees plus $3,608.61 in expenses for defending the judgment on appeal, according to WHAS11.

The inheritance

In post-judgment discovery, Davis said she owned no real estate, had made no large transfers and was not the beneficiary of any estate, the judge wrote. The couple's lawyers then found certified Rowan County records showing she inherited half of her mother's estate after her mother died in January 2025, and that she signed deeds in 2025 transferring property to family members.

A separate state lawsuit filed in July alleges that Davis and her brother inherited a property worth $735,230, and that between April and May 2025 Davis transferred her share to her brother, a sister-in-law, her husband and her son. Court filings put the cash value of her share at more than $200,000, WEKU reports.

"Defendant does not deny the existence of these certified public records, does not address if or why these documents are outside of the scope of Plaintiffs' requests, and gives no reason for not producing complete responses and documents," Adkins wrote.

No contempt, yet

The judge declined to hold Davis in contempt for now. Her attorneys have argued the federal motions are premature until the state case, in which Ermold and Moore are trying to undo the transfers, is resolved. The couple's lawyer, Michael Gartland, told WEKU he may appeal the decision not to hold her in contempt. "I would have held her in contempt because this court already held her in contempt and put her in jail years ago for failing to issue the licenses after the court ordered her to do so," he said, as quoted by GO Magazine.

Why it matters beyond Kentucky

Davis became a symbol of resistance to marriage equality in the United States, and her case has stayed in the headlines for a decade. For couples who marry, travel and build lives across borders, the lesson of the Ermold and Moore case is a practical one: rights on paper are enforced, slowly, in courtrooms, and sometimes the final chapter is about collecting what a jury already decided.

Sunday's deadline is the next marker. The Bond will follow what Davis files, and whether the court finally ends a decade-long chase.